I like the random requests :) They intrigue me! Although I very rarely have useful input, because I simply don't have the mainstream knowledge needed...

I think isiscolo's idea of "Best Performance By A Place Pretending To Be Another Place" is good *g*.

How about something like:
- Most Hilariously Inappropriate Music Choice In A Film Score? (I read a review of something earlier which mentioned the use of a contemporary pop-song for a dance between two nineteenth century characters.)
- Veteran Actor Most Obviously Desperate For Money? (Think, for instance, Jeremy Irons in the appalling Dungeons and Dragons film)
- Worst Case of Nepotism (by which I mean those people who apparently make it as actors purely based on being related to someone good)
- Bulwer Lytton Award for Prose (bad dialogue, perhaps?)
- Hed Pastede On Yay Award (obviously that name wouldn't do *g*. But something for really obviously bad special effects)