Thank god for Dean's dorkiness, seriously. I finally figured out on rewatch what bothered me so much about young!Dean in "After School Special"—it wasn't that he looked wrong, really, but that he was played so straight (er, not in the heterosexual sense), with none of the offbeat goofiness Jensen brings to the role. And that is just not my Dean. No.

So, he's my kind of stud. ;-)

Papa Winchester had it coming. *ducks*