The only story I definitively identified was astolat's, probably because I have been reading her since HP.

However, two things made me think this one was you:

Rodney would hit John with his pillow, but then John would stop rubbing his shoulder like that. And that would be sad.

The construction of this passage just sounded like your stuff. Also, the Vermont mention. When I read it, I immediately thought "This one time, in Vermont..."